DE Shaving Blade Sampler Pack
November 19th, 2008
I’ve been DE or double edged shaving for about three months now and getting the hang of the technique. The preparation of the skin, decent lather and short light strokes with the razor. I’ve been studying the direction of hair growth on my face and just generally taking my time pampering myself. I’ve tried a couple of blades namely the Merkur Platinum and Derby Extra. I find the Derby blades much smoother and sharper than the Merkur but I’m now wondering what else is out there.
From what I’ve read on the DE shaving forums such as badgerandblade you need to find blade that works best with your skin. A very personal choice that requires experimentation and research. So I’ve bought myself a blade sampler pack from connaught shaving comprising of 8 packs of blades. I chose some of them according to reviews and some at random. Obviously it’s not good to go by reviews because I’m doing my own but just to get a rough idea of what most people seem to like. But it was good to read that some people didn’t get on with the ones that most people seemed to like.
My testing method
As I don’t have a huge amount of experience with DE shaving what I’m going to do is to have 2 or 3 shaves with each blade and give it some sort of a rating. I’m aware that each blade in the pack is not equal as I discovered with the Derby Extra blades. I also can’t give it ratings under the many criteria as people seem to do on the forums as I don’t really appreciate some of those subtleties. What I’ll do then is to rate the blade on being sharp and smooth. So this process is going to take me roughly 8 weeks.
I’m not really fussed about the longevity of the blade as I’m interested in the quality of the shave first and foremost. Compared to multi blade replacements these are cheap and I don’t even shave every day. I’m also going to leave the Feather blades till last as they are supposed to be really good. In terms of an intuitive assessment they will be compared to the Derby Extra. If none of these blades can’t top them then I’ll stick with those until I find ones that are better on my face.
I have a scoring system in mind where the baseline is the Derby level which is also zero. And then plus or minus the Derby level in terms of smoothness and sharpness. My perceived ideas of what is sharp and what is smooth and not objective levels.
Not the same in every razor
Just as electric guitars need to be matched with a suitable amplifier so razor blades need to be matched with the right razor. From what I’ve read blades behave differently in different razors. I’ve only got one razor the Merkur HD so it will be the blade that behaves best in that razor. So I guess ultimately it will be a combination of blade, razor and skin.
Even though I have only the one razor I can see myself acquiring a few more in the not too distant future but not before the end of these tests. I’ve been looking at them on ebay but they seem to jump in price rather quickly. I’ve been looking at vintage Gillettes thinking that they will go for a song but collectors seem to have their eye on them.
What of other factors such as lather?
To keep these tests accurate I would need to keep all the other factors constant such as the lather, the amount of preparation, the temperature of the water and time of day of the shave. I guess I should do that in order to maintain a sense of accuracy and scientific precision but I probably won’t. Sometimes I’ll have a shower before the shave and sometimes I won’t. Sometimes I’ll use the shaving cream and sometimes the stick. But won’t that invalidate my results? It will reduce the accuracy but won’t invalidate the final results. I will still have a feel of which ones performed best. And they will also be tested under various conditions. This is a hobby after all and not an article for Which? magazine. But hey, perhaps I could sell it to them.






